Lab 3 - BitBombs

Assigned:	Wednesday, February 28.
Checkpoint 1:	Wednesday, March 7. Phases 1 and 2 should be defused by this checkpoint.
Checkpoint 2:	Thursday, March 29. Phases 3 and 4 should be defused by this checkpoint.
Due Date:	Monday, April 2. All phases should be defused.
Collaboration Policy:	Level 1 (refer to the official policy for details)
Group Policy:	Individual

This lab will give you experience with x86-64 machine code and reverse-engineering, in addition to extensive practice with the debugger. Your task is to defuse a BitBomb planted on the class server by reverse-engineering it to discover its defusal codes!

Note: Read through the full writeup before tackling your bitbomb - you should not immediately (and blindly) execute it!

Lab Overview

Agents of the nefarious organization BitBombs Inc. have infiltrated the CSCI 2330 server and planted a set of BitBombs on our machine. A BitBomb is a compiled executable program that consists of a sequence of six phases, each wired to explode and wreak havoc on our bits. The bitbombs are on timers and are set to detonate automatically at 11:59 pm on April 2. Luckily, each bitbomb contains a failsafe mechanism - each phase of the bitbomb can be bypassed if a specific defusal code is entered. However, if an incorrect defusal code is entered for any phase, the bitbomb will immediately explode.

There are too many bitbombs for your instructor to handle, so each of you will be provided with a bitbomb to defuse. Your task is to safely defuse your bitbomb before the detonation date. Good luck - our bits are counting on you!

BitBomb Files

Each of you has a set of files pertaining to your bitbomb that have been checked into your SVN directory under lab3. First, run svn update within your directory to download these files. Within the lab3 directory, there are several key files:

bitbomb: Your unique bitbomb executable.
bitbomb.c: Some code that BitBombs Inc. left lying around (we think it might be useful).
codes.txt: File in which you will write your defusal codes.
descriptions.txt: File in which you will describe your defusal solutions.
ID: File containing your unique BitBomb ID.

BitBomb Handling & Safety

warning Safety Notice: You should ONLY execute the bitbomb on the class server. Attempting to execute your bitbomb on any other machine will detonate it immediately!

Execute the bitbomb to begin the defusal process:

$ ./bitbomb

When executed, the bitbomb will wait for you to enter a defusal code, which will be passed to the current phase. If the code is correct, the phase will be bypassed and you will be prompted to enter the code for the next phase. If the code is incorrect, the bitbomb will explode. If you enter all six correct defusal codes, the bitbomb will be defused. Note that pressing enter without typing anything still constitutes submitting a defusal code!

warning Safety Notice: Our server has been outfitted with a bitbomb alarm system, which will automatically alert the instructor of bitbomb explosions. Practice safe bitbomb handling and don't blindly execute your bitbomb!

The bitbomb will start from phase 1 each time you execute it. To avoid having to re-enter earlier defusal codes each time you run the bitbomb, you should enter your codes in codes.txt as you discover them, one phase per line. Then, you can pass this file to your bitbomb when you execute it to automatically feed it your codes:

$ ./bitbomb codes.txt

Once all the codes from codes.txt have been given to the bitbomb, it will switch over to prompting for manual defusal codes as normal.

To discover the defusal codes and avoid accidentally setting off the bitbomb, you will need to use a debugger (GDB) to set breakpoints, step through the bitbomb, and inspect its state. However, this will be substantially more challenging than in the previous lab, because you will (mostly) not have any source code to reference! Instead, you will need to reverse-engineer your bitbomb by inspecting its assembly instructions.

To run the bitbomb using the debugger gdb and pass it a codes file, you can run the following:

$ gdb bitbomb
... startup messages from gdb ...
(gdb) run codes.txt

To run your bitbomb in gdb without passing it any initial codes, you can simply type run at the initial gdb prompt.

See the tools and advice sections below for more tips on defusing your bitbomb.

Tasks

You are responsible for two tasks:

Determining the correct defusal codes and entering them into codes.txt.
Documenting your methods and insights during reverse engineering in descriptions.txt.

You should organize your descriptions by phase (i.e., each phase should have a code and a corresponding description). Each description should be a short paragraph or two describing what the phase is doing with your input (to the best of your understanding), and how you determined the correct input.

The objective of your descriptions should not be a line-by-line explanation of what each individual assembly command is doing (though you'll largely need to understand that regardless), but rather to show that you understand how the entire phase fits together at a higher level. Ideally, your documentation should describe the behavior of the phase at the level of comments you might write for a regular C program. You may not understand every aspect of what each phase is doing (and that's okay) but your descriptions should explain what insights you've learned and how they led you to discovering your defusal codes.

Note that a description like "I tried a bunch of random codes and this one worked" is not a good description! Even if you happen to stumble across a working defusal code, you should still try to understand what the phase is actually doing.

Defusal Toolkit

There are many approaches you can take to defusing your bitbomb. You can examine your bitbomb in great detail without ever executing it to figure out how it works. You can also execute the bitbomb using a debugger to run it step by step and examine the state of the machine along the way (while also giving you a chance to bail out before it explodes!). A mix of these two approaches is probably most efficient.

First, you should not use brute force to defuse your bitbomb! While you could theoretically write a program to try many defusal codes on your bitbomb, this is a bad idea for several reasons. One, the number of possibilities is so large that you are unlucky to solve your bitbomb using this approach. Two, a brute force approach will not allow you to write a very good description of your reverse engineering approach. Three, a brute force approach is likely to result in repeatedly detonating your bitbomb!

There are many tools that are designed to help you figure out how programs work and what is wrong when they do not work. You are likely to find the following tools helpful in particular:

gdb will allow you to trace through the bitbomb instruction by instruction, examine the contents of memory and registers, look at the assembly code (and the source code if available...which it mostly isn't in this case), set breakpoints, and more. Refer to the GDB Reference Sheet for useful gdb commands.
objdump is a program that can output various types of information about compiled (aka 'object') files. The two uses of objdump that you will likely find most useful are objdump -t bitbomb and objdump -d bitbomb. The former (-t) will print out the bitbomb's symbol table, which includes the names of all functions and global variables in the program, as well as their addresses. These names may be useful! The latter (-d) will dump a complete assembly instruction listing of the program (i.e., it will disassemble the entire program). You may note, however, that certain things in this assembly instruction listing are cryptic, particularly the names of system library functions that are called. Some of this information is presented more usefully when the code is disassembled from within gdb (i.e., while the program is running) - the reason for this has to do with linking and loading, some of which happens at runtime. You can disassemble within gdb using the disas command, which will usually give you the most information about the assembly instructions.
strings is a utility that will output all the printable, literal strings contained in a program. A useful way to run it is as follows:
```
strings -t x bitbomb
```
The above will output all the strings and their hex offsets in the program.
You may wish to save the output of running objdump or strings for later reference. You can easily do this using output redirection, like so:
```
progname arg1 > output.txt
```
The above will run progname arg1 and dump the output into a file called output.txt (of course, substitute whatever program, argument(s), and filename you actually want).

If you encounter x86-64 assembly instructions with which you are not familiar, you can consult the textbook, Google, or go right to the source and check the the official Intel architecture manuals. Remember when consulting references that we're using x86-64, not the 32-bit x86 (aka IA32).

Tips and Advice

The following pieces of advice are well worth heeding as you tackle your bitbomb:

Safety Notice: Don't let your bitbomb explode! The most reliable way to safeguard against inadvertent explosions is to set breakpoints within gdb such that the bitbomb will be interrupted before it explodes, giving you a chance to exit out and try again if you enter a wrong code. Make a habit of setting this breakpoint to give yourself an insurance policy!
Remember that you can type Control-C to interrupt execution of a program that you're executing directly (i.e., outside of gdb). Although BitBombs Inc. was rumored to be working on a mechanism to defeat attempts to interrupt the bitbomb, so let's hope that feature doesn't work yet...
Don't try to understand everything! When looking at assembly code, it is easy to go down the rabbit hole and find yourself staring at hundreds of instructions that may only be tangentially related to what you're actually investigating. Be methodical about what sections you should focus your attention on and what sections you can skim over. For example, if you can piece together how a helper function works using only the function name and a bit of trial and error, you can probably skip looking at the instructions of the helper function altogether.
Take notes liberally while reverse engineering. Taking notes goes beyond writing your 'polished' notes which should be entered in descriptions.txt. You will be looking at a lot of instructions, register names, symbols, and memory addresses in the course of reverse engineering, and keeping everything in your head is likely to be difficult. Jot down notes along the way so you don't have to do the process all over again to remember how it worked!
Start early! Trying to defuse the bitbomb five minutes before detonation might make for a good TV episode, but it's unlikely to result in a successful defusal.
The display command in gdb is quite useful - it allows you to print expressions automatically (registers, memory contents, etc) every time execution stops.
The phases are progressively more difficult. Think of phase 1 like the reverse-engineering equivalent of writing "Hello World" and plan accordingly.
We intercepted a BitBombs Inc. communication that mentioned something about a secret phase 7. Probably nothing, but keep your eyes open...

Evaluation

Your final submission will consist of your committed files at the time of the due date, as well as the automatically submitted results of executing your bitbomb.

You will be evaluated both on determining the correct defusal codes for each phase as well as clearly documenting your methods and insights during reverse-engineering in descriptions.txt. Points for each phase are given below (of which roughly half will be from your solution and half from your description):

Phase 1: 10 points
Phase 2: 20 points
Phase 3: 20 points
Phase 4: 20 points
Phase 5: 20 points
Phase 6: 10 points

warning Safety Notice: Repeated detonations of your bitbomb may have a negative impact on your score as well as our bits!

Partial credit is possible on unsolved phases for clear documentation that demonstrates effort and some understanding of the phase. Full credit requires both correct defusal codes and high-quality descriptions!

Disarmanent Status Report

To assist us in tracking the server-wide defusal effort, we have created an online Disarmament Status Report page (active for the duration of the lab). The status report page will show your progress towards defusing your bomb as well as the progress made by your classmates. You can also see your total number of bitbomb explosions on this page. Entries are identified by bitbomb ID, which is contained in your ID file.

Defusal and detonation notifications are automatically logged by the server and require no action on your part.